Hertz $1.55M CCPA Fine: Cookie Toggles Showed Off While Ad Cookies Stayed On

UniConsent Team

7 min read
Add UniConsent as a preferred source on Google
Table of contents

The California Privacy Protection Agency (CalPrivacy) has fined The Hertz Corporation $1.55 million under the CCPA. If your website runs advertising tags and offers a cookie preferences window, the order shows two things to check: that Global Privacy Control (GPC) stops those tags before they load, and that the choices your window displays are the choices it actually applies.

Hertz $1.55M CCPA Fine: Cookie Toggles Showed Off While Ad Cookies Stayed OnHertz $1.55M CCPA Fine: Cookie Toggles Showed Off While Ad Cookies Stayed On

The Board adopted the decision on November 6, 2026 and the agency announced it on November 17. It covers Hertz.com, Dollar.com, Thrifty.com and their apps. It is the agency's second-largest fine so far, after the $2.975 million FedEx order a week earlier. Hertz agreed to the order without admitting liability, and the agency notes that it cooperated and fixed issues during the investigation.

What the Order Says

The order covers July 1, 2023 to August 25, 2026, and makes three findings.

GPC signals were not honoured

Hertz's sites loaded trackers from Meta, Google, Pinterest, LinkedIn, Microsoft, TikTok, The Trade Desk, LiveRamp, Adobe, Amazon, Sojern, Criteo, Wunderkind and other ad tech companies. These made identifiers and rental details, such as car rental dates, available for cross-context behavioural advertising. Some of the companies also synced their cookies with each other to recognise the same person across their systems.

For part of that period, Hertz "failed to configure its digital properties to properly detect and honor consumers' opt-out preference signals". Visitors who had GPC turned on kept having their data sold and shared with ad tech companies and data brokers.

The privacy policy did not explain the signals

For part of the period, Hertz's privacy policy did not say how it processes opt-out preference signals or how visitors can use one. The CCPA regulations require both.

The "Manage Cookies" window showed a choice it had not saved

This is the new finding. On Dollar.com and Thrifty.com, the "Manage Cookies" link opened a window with toggles for functionality, performance and advertising cookies. Every toggle appeared to be off.

But the off position was only a display. If a visitor closed the window with the "X" instead of clicking "Save Changes", nothing was stored and the site went back to its default, which allowed advertising cookies. A visitor who saw advertising cookies switched off had no reason to think they still needed to act.

The agency said this choice architecture "may have been confusing". Under the CCPA regulations, toggles must clearly show the consumer's choice, and opt-out methods must not rely on confusing interactive elements.

What Hertz Has to Do Now

The obligations run for three years:

  • Check for the GPC signal before loading any tracker that sells or shares personal information
  • Follow the instructions from its tag manager, consent platform and ad partners on how to apply opt-outs, for example by sending a restricted data processing flag to service providers
  • Test opt-outs every quarter in staging and production, on every site, tag container, browser and mobile platform, for client-side and server-side trackers, for first-time visitors with no consent yet, for visitors who change their consent, and whether they opt out with GPC or the cookie banner
  • Not rely only on what its consent management platform says, and check at least twice a year that the platform handles CCPA requests correctly
  • Scan its sites and apps every quarter for trackers that sell or share data, and keep CCPA contracts with each third party
  • Publish CCPA request numbers every year, counting opt-outs that came from GPC separately

Hertz must pay the fine within 60 days and make the changes within 180 days.

Lessons for Your Website

The toggles must match what is saved

Open your own cookie preferences window and close it without saving. Then check what loads on the next page. If the window shows advertising cookies off on first open, that must already be the stored state. If it is not, show the real current state, or save the choice as soon as the visitor changes a toggle.

GPC has to be checked before tags load

Detecting GPC after the Meta Pixel or a Google tag has already fired is too late. The order says the check must happen before any tracker that sells or shares data is loaded. Put your consent check ahead of every advertising tag, including ones added by your tag manager.

Test what visitors actually do

Hertz now has to test first visits, changed choices, GPC and cookie banner opt-outs separately. Do the same on your site: turn on GPC in Firefox or Brave, load a page and look at the network tab. Then repeat with GPC off, opt out in the banner, and close the preferences window in every way it can be closed.

The order tells Hertz not to rely solely on what its consent platform claims. Whichever tool you use, check yourself that opt-outs stop the tags, and check again after every new tag or site change.

How UniConsent Helps

UniConsent detects GPC in the visitor's browser and opts that visitor out automatically, without them opening the notice. With the Tags Loader, advertising tags such as the Meta Pixel and Google tags only load after the consent check, and the opt-out is passed on to your ad partners through IAB GPP.

UniConsent also adds the "Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information" link for US state privacy laws, scans your site every day for new cookies, and keeps a record of every choice so you can check what was saved.

FAQ

Did Hertz admit to breaking the law? No. Hertz admitted background facts, including that it sold and shared personal information for cross-context behavioural advertising. It neither admits nor denies the other findings and does not admit liability.

Is a cookie banner enough to comply with the CCPA? Only if it works. The toggles must clearly show the visitor's choice, the choice must be saved and applied, and GPC must be honoured even if the visitor never opens the banner.

How do I check whether my site honours GPC? Open your site in a browser with GPC enabled and run navigator.globalPrivacyControl in the console. Then watch the network tab for requests to advertising vendors. If they still fire, the signal is not being honoured.

Were other companies fined at the same time? Yes. The same day, the Board ordered clothing retailer Filson to pay $217,987 and to stop sharing data with ad tech companies until it certifies compliance. See all cases in our privacy fines tracker.

Sign up and set up GPC and US opt-outs on your website in a few minutes.

References

About UniConsent

UniConsent is a certified Consent Management Platform (CMP) by the EU IAB and IAB Canada. It is also a Google-certified CMP Partner at the Gold tier. Contact us to learn more: hello@uniconsent.com

Get started to make your website and application compliant for EU GDPR, US CPRA, CA PIPEDA etc

Sign up

Get started to make your website and application compliant for EU GDPR, US CPRA, CA PIPEDA etc

Sign up

Stay ahead on privacy and consent

Privacy laws, consent and compliance updates, a few emails a month.

No spam, unsubscribe any time. Privacy